According to the National Sexual Violence Resource Center, approximately one in five undergraduate women are raped or experience sexual assault in college. In order to change this statistic, it is crucial that universities such as Cornell and educational leaders take action to limit, punish and discourage sexual assault on college campuses. Cornell University’s idea of punishing the male assaulters (specifically five of “The Cornell Seven”) is extremely inadequate and fails to bring justice to Jane Doe, whose suffering on the evening of Oct. 19, 2024, needs to be met with harsh penalties.
Let’s go back to where it all began. A woman recognized as Jane Doe has accused seven men, current or former students at Cornell University, of gang-raping her on Oct. 19, 2024. According to The New York Times, On Sept. 16. 2026, Doe filed a civil lawsuit against Cornell University, the Chi Phi fraternity as well as seven of its members. Doe alleged that she was coerced, drugged and repeatedly assaulted over a span of seven hours. Those being held responsible, seven men from the Chi Phi fraternity house at Cornell University, were identified by Doe, incriminated by evidence from social media and are now defendants in Doe’s 101-page lawsuit. According to The New York Times, these men were found responsible for participating or bystanding in the gang-rape by Cornell’s Title IX panel after a 12-day hearing led to the discovery that Jane Doe’s consent had, in fact, been violated after one of them posted an open invitation to take advantage of Doe during her incapacitated state in a Snapchat group.
As more details of this case are being publicized, this issue has generated a massive social uprising. Its significance, both in media and on college campuses, is causing people to once again question the role of patriarchy in society as well as to argue that justice is being inhibited by the leniency that leaders give men.
Like Cornell University’s leaders, for example. According to The New York Times, two of the seven men were expelled, two were suspended and another (who had graduated prior to the discipline panel’s decision) was prohibited from entering campus for three years. The other two men were given punishments far less in severity such as writing “reflection” pieces and reviewing the concept of sexual harassment. It is debatable whether or not their disciplines are actually ‘punishments.’
Cornell’s actions signify that a crime as heinous as sexually assaulting a woman for seven hours, or even being a bystander to this atrocity, is excusable by a suspension or mere words on paper. It allows other men to think they can do the same, as the standard for punishment is clearly worthless enough to motivate the crime. While these five men may not have been the ‘ringleaders’ of the ordeal, they still actively partook in the evening in which Jane Doe was assaulted. Whether or not they initiated the gang-raping doesn’t change the fact that it happened, that they were a crucial part of it and that they had every opportunity to end it yet chose not to.
I strongly believe that by delegating these offenders lesser punishments, Cornell is both denying full justice to Jane Doe, and failing to teach a proper lesson in response to a brutal crime. Not only is sexual assault a crime against morality, but it is also one against justice valued and maintained by the United States government.
According to the United States Department of Justice, sexual assault is defined by “any nonconsensual sexual act proscribed by federal, tribal, or state law, including when the victim lacks capacity to consent.” In other words, sexual assault is regarded by the United States government as illegal. The government mandates that all crime must be punished accordingly so that perpetrators must suffer the consequences of their wrongdoings to attain justice and to discourage others from committing the same acts. That is why punishments exist: to teach lessons. Universities are completely accountable for imposing those consequences and warnings on students.
Yes, Cornell’s punishments of expulsion for two of the seven men were acceptable. Men like them do not deserve to be present on a college campus where they have proven likely to exercise harsh, manipulative behaviors. The other five men, who were not expelled, received their lesser punishments because they were not responsible for initiating the gang-raping. However, they still escalated the situation by participating and bystanding. Because of this, I believe that the rest of “The Cornell Seven” deserves the same level of repercussion as the two men who were expelled.
According to New York Post, Cornell has hired an outside law firm to analyze the merits of their actions after the Title IX investigation. It is important to note that Cornell is not held accountable for criminal proceedings (which are in the hands of the state’s judicial system), which means there is a limit on the justice the university’s actions can bring. However, that bar of justice must be met with severe consequences nonetheless.
In short, sexual assault is a felonious violence that must be prevented and counteracted by harsh consequences. Cornell University failed to abide by this principle, which means it is up to us as a society, and those who lead, to advocate for and ensure the safety of every single womanlike Jane Doe. This entails that when a man sexually assaults an innocent woman, leaders must not place a piece of paper in front of him and merely ask his dissimulating hand to write. The severity of the crime must be met with an equal punishment that ensures both morality and justice, which means Cornell and other universities must give the harshest possible punishments to assaulters to ensure they do not assault again.
